By Timileyin Ilesanmi
You paid for goods, services, land, or a business transaction, but the other party never delivered. The question is no longer simply whether you are disappointed; it is whether the law will compel performance, order a refund, or award compensation for the loss caused by the failure.
Nigerian law recognises that a party who has paid for a benefit that was never received should not be left without a remedy. But the appropriate remedy depends on the contract, the nature of the breach, whether performance is still possible, and whether the buyer wants the goods or simply wants their money back.
What remedies are available where one party has performed its obligation by paying, while the other party has failed to deliver or perform? The buyer must establish that a binding contract existed, that payment was made, that the other party failed to perform, and that the failure was not excused by a valid contractual term, frustration, or other legal defence.
A contract is formed where there is offer, acceptance, consideration, intention to create legal relations, and capacity. Once these elements exist, non-performance may amount to a breach. The remedy is not automatic; the buyer must choose between restitution, damages, rescission, and, in limited cases, specific performance.
Refund and restitution
The most direct remedy is often restitution: the return of money paid where the consideration has wholly failed. Where a buyer pays an advance or deposit for goods or services that are never supplied, the seller may be required to refund the payment because it would be unjust for the seller to retain money for a benefit never delivered.
Nigerian courts apply the principle that money paid for a consideration that has totally failed may be recovered. In G.E. International Operations (Nig.) Ltd. v. Q-Oil & Gas Services Ltd. (2016) 10 NWLR (Pt. 1520) 304, the Supreme Court explained that damages for breach of contract are assessed on the principle of restitution in integrum, placing the injured party, so far as money can do so, in the position they would have occupied had the breach not occurred.
Where the contract has been partly performed, the position is more nuanced. If some goods were delivered or some services were rendered, the buyer may not be entitled to a full refund. The court may assess the value of the performance actually received and order repayment only for the unperformed portion, subject to the contract’s terms.
Damages for non-delivery
Where the buyer still needs the goods or services, damages may be more appropriate than a refund. Damages compensate the buyer for the loss directly and naturally resulting from the seller’s failure to deliver. Under section 51 of the Sale of Goods Act 1893, where a seller wrongfully neglects or refuses to deliver goods, the buyer may sue for damages for non-delivery.
Where an available market exists, the usual measure of damages is the difference between the contract price and the market price at the time delivery was due. For example, if a buyer agreed to buy cement at N9,000 per bag but now has to buy replacement bags at N11,000 each, they can claim the N2,000 price difference for every undelivered bag—provided they show proof and took reasonable steps to reduce their losses.
The buyer must also mitigate loss. A buyer cannot sit back while prices rise and then claim an inflated loss. Reasonable steps to procure a substitute, reduce expense, or preserve the commercial benefit of the contract may affect the damages recoverable.
Rescission and specific performance
Rescission cancels the contract and restores the parties, so far as possible, to their pre-contract positions. It is particularly relevant where the seller’s breach goes to the root of the contract or where the buyer was induced to enter the contract by misrepresentation. Where rescission is available, the buyer may recover money paid, subject to restitution and any deductions for benefits received.
Specific performance is an equitable remedy that compels a party to perform the contract rather than merely pay damages. It is discretionary and is generally granted only where damages are inadequate. Under section 52 of the Sale of Goods Act 1893, a buyer may seek specific performance of a contract for specific or ascertained goods, particularly where the goods are unique, scarce, or otherwise difficult to replace.
A buyer cannot automatically demand specific performance for every failed delivery. Where ordinary goods are readily available in the market, damages are usually adequate. But where the subject matter is a unique property, bespoke equipment, or a scarce asset, a court may consider ordering performance.
Limitation and evidence
Time matters. A claim for breach of a simple contract is generally subject to a six-year limitation period under the Limitation Law of Lagos State, Cap. L84, Laws of Lagos State 2015. The period usually runs from the date the breach occurred or the date performance was due, depending on the nature of the obligation.
The buyer should preserve the contract, invoices, receipts, payment evidence, correspondence, delivery notes, photographs, and messages showing the agreement and the failure to deliver. These materials will be essential in proving the contract, the amount paid, the seller’s breach, and the loss suffered.
Final note
Before suing, review the contract for delivery dates, payment terms, cancellation clauses, dispute-resolution provisions, and remedies for breach. Send a clear demand letter requiring delivery or refund within a stated period, and preserve the seller’s response or silence.
If the seller has completely failed to perform, the buyer may seek a refund or rescission. If replacement goods or services are available, damages may be the better remedy. Where the subject matter is unique, the buyer may consider specific performance. The right remedy depends not only on the breach, but also on what the buyer realistically needs to restore their commercial position.