Your Business Partner Is Acting Against the Company: What Can You Do?

By Timileyin Ilesanmi

A business partnership does not always survive disagreement. A shareholder or director may divert company funds, award contracts to personal entities, exclude another shareholder from management, refuse to account for profits, or take decisions that damage the company’s value.

When that happens, the injured party must act carefully. The company—not the shareholder—is ordinarily the proper claimant for loss suffered by the company. But Nigerian law provides remedies where those in control abuse their positions or conduct the company’s affairs unfairly.

The legal issue

What remedies are available where a business partner, shareholder, or director acts against the company’s interest? The claimant must distinguish between a personal wrong suffered as a shareholder and a wrong suffered by the company itself. A shareholder may have a personal claim where they suffer direct loss, such as exclusion from dividends or improper dilution of their shareholding. However, where the company’s funds, contracts, assets, or business opportunities are harmed, the proper claimant is usually the company. The shareholder may then need to persuade the company to act or seek the court’s permission to sue on its behalf.

Directors’ duties

Directors occupy a fiduciary position. Under section 305 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020, a director owes duties of good faith and loyalty to the company. Section 306 requires directors to act honestly, in good faith, and in the best interests of the company, while exercising the care, diligence, and skill of a reasonably prudent director.

A director who diverts a company contract to a personal business, misappropriates company funds, awards contracts without disclosure, or uses confidential information for personal benefit may breach these duties. The company may seek damages, an account of profits, recovery of misapplied assets, or an injunction restraining further misconduct.

Directors are also individually and collectively liable for board decisions in which they participate. Section 308(3) of CAMA 2020 provides that directors are individually and collectively liable for the actions of the board in which they participate.

Oppression and unfair prejudice

Where the conduct harms a shareholder personally, the shareholder may petition the court under the unfair-prejudice provisions of CAMA 2020 (Sections 353 -356). The relevant provisions allow a member to seek relief where the company’s affairs are being conducted in a manner that is illegal, oppressive, unfairly prejudicial, or discriminatory.

Oppression involves conduct that is burdensome, harsh, wrongful, and lacking in probity or fair dealing. Unfair prejudice is broader and includes conduct that damages a shareholder’s interests or disregards their legitimate expectations, even where there is no deliberate intention to oppress.

Examples may include excluding a shareholder from management despite an agreement to participate, refusing to declare dividends while paying excessive directors’ remuneration, issuing new shares to dilute an existing shareholder, or transferring company assets to a director’s personal company. The remedy is not limited to winding up the company; the court may regulate the company’s affairs, restrain wrongful conduct, set aside transactions, order a share purchase, or award compensation.

Derivative actions

Where the company’s board refuses to sue a wrongdoing director or third party, a shareholder may seek leave to bring a derivative action under section 346 of CAMA 2020. A derivative action is brought in the company’s name, on behalf of the company, to recover loss suffered by the company rather than the shareholder personally.

The applicant must satisfy the court that the cause of action arises from an actual or proposed act or omission involving negligence, default, breach of duty, or breach of trust by a director. The applicant must also give reasonable notice to the directors, show that the directors are not diligently pursuing the claim, provide a factual basis for the alleged damage, and demonstrate that the application is brought in good faith.

The remedy may be pursued against the director, any other wrongdoer, or both. The proceeds of a successful derivative claim belong to the company, not the shareholder who brought the action.

Deadlock and winding up

Some disputes cannot be resolved by damages or an injunction. Where shareholders are equally divided and the company cannot function, the dispute may amount to deadlock. Where trust has broken down irretrievably, the court may consider winding up the company on just and equitable grounds.

Winding up is a remedy of last resort. It may be appropriate where the company has become a commercial failure, where there is a complete deadlock, or where the relationship between shareholders has broken down so completely that the company can no longer function as intended.

Before seeking winding up, the parties should consider negotiation, mediation, a buy-out, amendment of the shareholders’ agreement, or a court-sanctioned restructuring. These options may preserve value and avoid the cost and disruption of liquidation.

Final note

Shareholder disputes are best managed before they become litigation. A clear shareholders’ agreement should address share transfer, decision-making, dividends, deadlock, exit rights, valuation, and dispute resolution. Directors should document board decisions, disclose conflicts, and avoid using company assets for personal benefit.

Where misconduct has already occurred, preserve company records, demand an explanation in writing, and seek legal advice before taking unilateral action. The appropriate remedy depends on whether the wrong was suffered by the company or by the shareholder personally, and whether the company’s controllers are willing to act.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top