By Timileyin Ilesanmi
A court order is not a suggestion. Once a court makes a valid order, the party against whom it is made is expected to comply. Where a party refuses or neglects to obey an order, the affected party may seek enforcement through contempt or committal proceedings.
However, contempt proceedings are not automatic. Because they may result in imprisonment or other sanctions, Nigerian courts require strict compliance with procedure and clear proof that the order was disobeyed wilfully. The applicant must establish that a valid order exists, that its terms are clear, that the alleged contemnor had notice, and that the order was breached.
Contempt may arise where a party fails to do an act required by an order or does an act the order forbids. It may also arise from conduct that interferes with the administration of justice or brings the court into disrepute.
The legal position
In Atake v. Attorney-General of the Federation (1982) 11 S.C. (REPRINT) 63, the Supreme Court described contempt as conduct that tends to bring the authority and administration of the law into disrepute or that interferes with or prejudices litigants and witnesses in the course of litigation.
In Omoijahe v. Umoru (1999) 8 NWLR (Pt. 614) 178, the Supreme Court held that contempt flouts justice itself, not merely the individual judge or court attempting to administer it. The power to punish contempt is therefore exercised to protect the administration of justice, not the personal dignity of a judge.
Contempt may be committed in the face of the court, such as disruptive conduct during proceedings, or outside the court, such as disobedience to a subsisting order. The latter is the more common form in commercial and civil disputes.
Requirements for committal
In Uba v. Saipem Contracting Nigeria Ltd., the National Industrial Court restated the requirements for a successful committal application: there must be a subsisting valid order; the terms must be clear and unambiguous; the respondent must have proper notice; and there must be proof that the order was breached.
The order must also be capable of compliance. A party cannot be committed for failing to do something that is impossible, unlawful, or beyond its control. In Uba v. Saipem Contracting Nigeria Ltd., the respondents argued that they had taken genuine steps towards compliance but that the applicant frustrated the process; the court recognised that contempt requires deliberate disobedience.
The applicant bears the burden of proving the alleged contempt. Because committal may affect a person’s liberty, the standard is proof beyond reasonable doubt.
Service and procedure
For contempt arising from disobedience to an order other than an order to pay money, section 72 of the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act and Order 9 Rule 13 of the Judgment Enforcement Rules prescribe a strict procedure. The applicant must first obtain and personally serve Form 48, attached to the order and warning the recipient of the consequences of disobedience.
After at least two clear days, the applicant may obtain Form 49, which notifies the alleged contemnor that committal proceedings may be commenced. Only after service of both forms may the applicant file a motion on notice for committal.
In Ezeji v. Ike (1997) 2 NWLR (Pt. 486) 206, the court held that because committal proceedings may deprive a person of liberty, the service and procedure must be strictly applied; any departure may vitiate the proceedings.
Punishment and purging contempt
Where contempt is established, the court may commit the disobedient party to prison until the order is obeyed, impose a fine, or take other appropriate measures. The objective is not merely punishment; it is to secure compliance and uphold the authority of the court.
A party may avoid or purge contempt by complying with the order, providing a satisfactory explanation, or showing that compliance was impossible. Contempt may not be sustained where the alleged contemnor has taken bona fide and reasonable steps towards compliance.
The court will also consider whether the application is brought in good faith. A party cannot use contempt proceedings to harass an opponent or to circumvent the proper enforcement process.
Final note
A court order must be obeyed, but contempt is not a remedy to be invoked casually. The applicant must prove a clear order, proper notice, wilful breach, and strict compliance with the required procedure.
For parties seeking enforcement, preserve proof of service, document the disobedience, and act promptly. For parties served with an order, seek legal advice immediately and comply or explain any inability to comply. Ignoring a court order may turn a civil dispute into a serious challenge to personal liberty.