Can You Sue the Company—or Its Directors Personally?

By Timileyin Ilesanmi

When a company owes money, breaches a contract, or causes loss, the usual defendant is the company itself. A company is a separate legal person: it can own property, enter contracts, sue, and be sued in its own name. Its directors and shareholders are generally not personally liable simply because the company has failed.

However, that protection is not absolute. In limited circumstances, Nigerian courts may look behind the company and hold directors, officers, or controlling shareholders personally liable. The question is whether the corporate structure has been used to perpetrate fraud, evade legal obligations, or cause injustice. The claimant must identify the proper defendant and establish a legal basis for personal liability.

The starting position is that a properly incorporated company has a separate legal personality from its members. Section 42 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 recognises this separate personality, and the company’s debts and obligations are ordinarily its own.

The rule in Salomon

The foundational authority is Salomon v. Salomon & Co. Ltd. (1897) AC 22, where the House of Lords held that a company is separate from its shareholders, even where one person controls the company. The company’s debts are the company’s debts, not automatically those of its shareholders.

Nigerian courts apply the same principle. A company cannot be treated as the alter ego of its directors merely because it is closely held or controlled by one person. The corporate veil protects shareholders from personal liability for the company’s ordinary commercial obligations.

This principle encourages investment and limited-risk enterprise. But it cannot be used as a shield for fraud, illegality, or abuse of the corporate form.

Piercing the corporate veil

Piercing the corporate veil means disregarding the company’s separate personality and holding the individuals behind it personally liable. It is an exception, not the general rule, and Nigerian courts apply it cautiously.

The most common ground is fraud. Where a company is used to deceive creditors, conceal unlawful conduct, or evade legal obligations, the court may look behind the corporate structure and impose personal liability on those responsible.

In Marina Nominees Ltd. v. Federal Board of Inland Revenue (1986) 2 NWLR (Pt. 20) 48, the Supreme Court recognised that the corporate veil may be lifted where necessary to determine the true nature of a transaction, particularly in cases involving alleged tax evasion.

In Adeyemi v. Lan & Baker Nigeria Ltd. (2000) 7 NWLR (Pt. 663) 33, the court pierced the corporate veil where the company was used as a shield for fraudulent activity, breach of trust, or evasion of legal obligations.

Directors’ statutory duties

Directors owe fiduciary duties to the company. They must act in good faith, avoid conflicts of interest, and not misuse company property or information for personal benefit. Section 305 of CAMA 2020 imposes these duties, and no article, resolution, or contract can relieve a director from liability for breaching them.

A director who diverts company funds, awards contracts to himself, takes secret profits, or misuses confidential information may face personal liability. The company may sue the director to recover the loss or account for the profit.

These duties are owed to the company, not generally to individual shareholders. A shareholder who alleges wrongdoing by directors may therefore need to pursue a derivative action on behalf of the company, rather than a personal claim, depending on the nature of the wrong.

Fraudulent and wrongful trading

Where a company is insolvent, directors must be especially careful. Under CAMA 2020, fraudulent trading arises where the business of a company is carried on with intent to defraud creditors or for any fraudulent purpose. Directors and officers involved may be personally liable.

In African Continental Bank Ltd. v. Oladepo (1998) 10 NWLR (Pt. 568) 216, the court held directors personally liable to repay debts incurred by the company where their conduct allowed the company to continue trading despite insolvency.

The key issue is intent or reckless disregard for creditors’ interests. Mere commercial failure is not enough. A director must have knowingly allowed the company to incur obligations it could not meet, or acted dishonestly in the management of its affairs.

When directors are not liable

A director is not personally liable merely because the company owes money or loses a case. Liability requires a separate legal basis, such as a personal guarantee, fraudulent conduct, breach of fiduciary duty, statutory liability, or abuse of the corporate form.

A creditor should therefore identify the true source of the obligation. If the debt was incurred by the company, the claim should ordinarily be against the company. If a director personally guaranteed the debt, the claim may also lie against the director under the guarantee.

A claimant should not assume that suing the director will improve recovery. Without a proper legal basis, the claim may fail and expose the claimant to costs.

Final note

A company is not merely a name on a certificate. It is a separate legal person, and its directors and shareholders are generally protected from personal liability for its obligations. That protection may be lost where the corporate structure is used for fraud, evasion, or abuse.

Before filing a claim, identify the proper defendant and assess whether there is a legal basis for personal liability. For directors, the safest protection is not a carefully drafted shareholder agreement, but transparent governance, proper records, and compliance with fiduciary and statutory duties.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top