You Won Your Case, But the Debtor Still Refuses to Pay—What Next?

By Timileyin Ilesanmi

Winning a lawsuit is an important victory, but it is not always the end of the dispute. A judgment in your favour does not automatically transfer money from the debtor’s account or hand over property. The debtor may ignore the judgment, deny receipt, or claim that they have no assets.

When that happens, the judgment creditor must move from obtaining judgment to enforcing it. Nigerian law provides several mechanisms to convert a court judgment into actual recovery, but the choice of remedy depends on the debtor’s assets and the nature of the judgment.

How can a judgment creditor enforce a monetary judgment where the judgment debtor refuses or fails to pay? The creditor must identify the debtor’s assets, select the appropriate enforcement procedure, and comply with the procedural rules governing execution.

A judgment is enforceable only after it has become final or where execution is permitted despite an appeal. The creditor cannot simply seize the debtor’s property or freeze accounts without a court order. Enforcement must follow the law, or the creditor may face liability for unlawful execution.

Garnishee proceedings

Garnishee proceedings are often the most effective remedy where the debtor has money in a bank account. The procedure is governed by sections 83 to 92 of the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act. It allows the judgment creditor to attach money owed to the judgment debtor by a third party, usually a bank.

The creditor first applies for a garnishee order nisi. This is a conditional order directing the bank to appear and show cause why the money in the debtor’s account should not be applied to satisfy the judgment. If the bank does not dispute liability or show sufficient cause, the court may make an order absolute, requiring the bank to pay the funds directly to the judgment creditor.

Garnishee proceedings are particularly useful because they target liquid assets. They may also be used against a debtor’s customers or debtors, where money is due to the judgment debtor from a third party.

Writ of fieri facias

Where the debtor has no accessible bank funds, the creditor may seek a writ of fieri facias, commonly called a writ of fifa. This writ authorises the sheriff or court bailiff to seize and sell the debtor’s movable property to satisfy the judgment debt.

The writ may be issued against goods, vehicles, equipment, and other movable assets belonging to the debtor. Certain essential items, such as basic household necessities and tools of trade, may be protected from execution.

Where the proceeds from movable property are insufficient, the creditor may seek attachment and sale of the debtor’s immovable property. In Cole v. Jibunoh (2016) 4 NWLR (Pt. 1503) 499, the creditor recovered only a small amount from the debtor’s movable property and then obtained an order for attachment and sale of immovable property to satisfy the outstanding balance.

Judgment-debtor summons

A judgment-debtor summons is a useful tool where the creditor does not know the debtor’s assets or financial position. It requires the debtor to appear in court and answer questions on oath about their means, income, bank accounts, property, and ability to pay.

The procedure is governed by sections 55 and 68 of the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act. If the debtor fails to appear or fails to show cause, the court may issue a warrant of arrest and, in appropriate circumstances, commit the debtor for contempt.

The purpose is not to imprison a person merely because they are poor. It is to compel disclosure and ensure that a debtor with means does not wilfully refuse or neglect to satisfy a judgment debt.

Other enforcement options

Depending on the nature of the judgment, the creditor may also seek a warrant of possession, particularly where the judgment concerns recovery of land or premises. A writ of attachment of immovable property may be used where land or buildings must be sold to satisfy the debt.

Sequestration may be available where a party disobeys a court order, while committal proceedings may be used to punish contempt. These remedies are discretionary and require strict compliance with procedural requirements.

Where the debtor is a company, the creditor may also consider insolvency proceedings if the debt is substantial and the company is unable to pay. However, enforcement against a company does not automatically expose directors personally unless the law or facts support personal liability.

Final note

A judgment is only as valuable as the debtor’s recoverable assets. Before filing a claim, a creditor should assess the debtor’s financial position, identify bank accounts, property, vehicles, receivables, and other assets that may be available for enforcement.

After judgment, act promptly. Obtain a certified copy of the judgment, conduct asset searches, and choose the enforcement mechanism most likely to produce recovery. A judgment creditor should not assume that the debtor will pay voluntarily; enforcement is often where the real work of debt recovery begins.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top