You Have a Strong Case—But Can This Court Actually Hear It?

By Timileyin Ilesanmi

A claimant may have convincing evidence, a clear contract, and a compelling story, yet still lose the case before the merits are considered. The reason may be jurisdiction: the court may lack the legal authority to hear the dispute at all.

Jurisdiction is the foundation of every lawsuit. It determines whether a court can entertain the subject matter, bind the parties, and grant the relief sought. A judgment delivered without jurisdiction is a nullity, no matter how well reasoned it may appear. The issue is whether the court in which an action is filed has jurisdiction to hear and determine the dispute. Jurisdiction is not a technicality; it is the court’s legal authority to adjudicate.

In Nigerian civil litigation, jurisdiction has three principal dimensions: subject-matter jurisdiction, territorial jurisdiction, and jurisdiction over the parties. The claimant must establish that the court has authority over the type of dispute, the place where the dispute arose or the defendant resides, and the persons sought to be bound by the judgment.

Subject-matter jurisdiction

Subject-matter jurisdiction concerns the type of claim the court is competent to hear. The Federal High Court is a court of limited jurisdiction, deriving its authority from section 251(1) of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999, as amended. Its jurisdiction covers specified federal matters, including revenue, taxation, banking and financial institutions, companies, bankruptcy, and certain federal government disputes.

A simple contract or debt-recovery claim that has no connection with any federal matter is ordinarily within the jurisdiction of a State High Court, not the Federal High Court. In Usman v. Nig. Unity Line Plc (2025) 15 NWLR (Pt. 2008) 267, the Supreme Court ruled that, under Section 251(1) of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (as amended), the Federal High Court lacks the jurisdiction to entertain debt recovery or other claims arising from simple contracts, as such matters fall outside its statutory scope.

The State High Court, by contrast, has wider residual civil jurisdiction. It may hear civil disputes involving legal rights, duties, obligations, liabilities, and claims that do not fall within the exclusive jurisdiction of another court.

Territorial jurisdiction

Even where a court has subject-matter jurisdiction, it must also have territorial jurisdiction. A State High Court generally exercises jurisdiction within its state or judicial division, based on the location of the dispute, the defendant’s residence, or the place where the cause of action arose.

A claimant cannot simply file a Lagos contract dispute in another state because it is more convenient. The proper forum is usually the state where the defendant resides or carries on business, or where the contract was to be performed. Where the defendant has no connection with the chosen jurisdiction, the defendant may challenge the court’s territorial competence.

Territorial jurisdiction is particularly important in commercial disputes involving parties in different states. A contract may specify a venue for litigation, but a forum-selection clause does not automatically cure a lack of statutory jurisdiction.

Jurisdiction over parties

A court must also have jurisdiction over the defendant. This usually depends on proper service of the originating process and the defendant’s connection with the court’s territory. Service is the formal means by which a defendant is notified of the claim and brought under the court’s authority.

Where a defendant is outside the court’s jurisdiction, the claimant may need leave to serve the process outside the jurisdiction. The court will consider whether the claim has a sufficient connection with the forum and whether service can be effected in accordance with the applicable rules. Improper service may deprive the court of jurisdiction and render subsequent proceedings vulnerable.

A defendant may be a company, an individual, a government agency, or a foreign entity. The proper defendant must be identified. Suing the wrong entity may result in the claim being struck out, even where the underlying transaction is clear.

Raising the objection

Jurisdiction can be raised at any stage of the proceedings, including on appeal. In Nwaobakata & Anor v. Osigor & Ors (SUIT NO.: NICN/PHC/110/2017), the Court affirmed that an objection to jurisdiction may be raised through pleadings, a motion, a preliminary objection, or even orally.

The Supreme Court’s position is equally firm. In FCE, Oyo v. Akinyemi (2008) 15 NWLR (Pt. 1109) 28, the Court held that jurisdiction is determined by the claimant’s claims and that an objection should be raised as early as possible where the court lacks jurisdiction on the face of the pleadings.

A jurisdictional objection is therefore not waived by delay. The court must resolve it before proceeding to the merits, because a judgment without jurisdiction is void.

Final note

Before filing, a claimant should identify the correct court, the proper parties, the place of performance or residence, and any statutory jurisdictional requirements. A claimant should also review any arbitration clause, exclusive jurisdiction clause, or statutory forum requirement before choosing a court.

A defendant should examine the originating process immediately. If the court lacks subject-matter or territorial jurisdiction, or if service is defective, the defendant should raise the objection promptly. A jurisdictional challenge may prevent unnecessary expense, delay, and exposure to an unenforceable judgment.

A strong case cannot survive a jurisdictional defect. The court must first have authority over the subject matter, the territory, and the parties before it can decide who is right.

For claimants, choosing the wrong forum may waste time and money. For defendants, jurisdiction is often the first line of defence. In either situation, the starting question is not whether the claim is strong, but whether the court can lawfully hear it.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top