Can a Court Stop Someone From Acting Before Your Case Ends?

By Timileyin Ilesanmi

A party may win a case after years of litigation, only to discover that the subject matter has been sold, destroyed, transferred, or irreversibly altered. To prevent that outcome, Nigerian courts may grant an interlocutory injunction—an order preserving the position pending the final determination of the case.

An interlocutory injunction is not a final declaration of ownership or liability. It is a protective order designed to prevent a party from taking action that would make the eventual judgment ineffective.

So, when can a court restrain a party from acting before the substantive dispute is decided? The applicant must show that the relief is necessary to preserve the subject matter of the case, prevent irreparable harm, and maintain a fair balance between the parties.

An interlocutory injunction is commonly sought in disputes involving land, company shares, contracts, debt recovery, employment, intellectual property, and commercial transactions. It may restrain a party from selling property, transferring shares, interfering with possession, terminating a contract, or dealing with disputed assets.

The legal test

The leading authority is Kotoye v. C.B.N (1989) 1 NWLR (Pt. 98) 419, where the Supreme Court set out the principles for granting an interlocutory injunction. The applicant must show a legal right to be protected, a serious question to be tried, and that the balance of convenience favours granting the injunction.

The applicant must also show that damages will not be adequate compensation if the injunction is refused, and that there has been no undue delay in bringing the application. Finally, the applicant must ordinarily give an undertaking in damages, meaning they accept responsibility to compensate the respondent if it later turns out that the injunction was wrongly granted.

These requirements are cumulative. A court will not grant an injunction merely because the applicant alleges urgency or asserts a strong claim. The applicant must establish a real legal risk that cannot be adequately remedied by money at the end of the case.

Serious question to be tried

The applicant must show that there is a serious question or substantial issue to be tried. This does not mean the applicant must prove the entire case at the interlocutory stage. It means the applicant must show that the claim is not frivolous, speculative, or hopeless.

For example, a shareholder alleging that directors intend to sell company assets in breach of their duties must produce evidence of the alleged transaction, the company’s interest in the assets, and the risk of irreparable harm. A landowner seeking to restrain a trespasser must show a legally protected interest in the property and a real dispute over possession or title.

The court will consider the affidavit evidence, the documents exhibited, and the nature of the legal right asserted. A bare assertion that the respondent intends to act unlawfully is usually insufficient.

Balance of convenience

The balance of convenience asks which party will suffer greater harm if the injunction is granted or refused before the case is decided. The court weighs the harm to the applicant if the respondent is allowed to proceed, against the harm to the respondent if the respondent is restrained.

Where a disputed property is about to be sold, the court may consider whether a sale would destroy the subject matter of the litigation or make restoration impossible. Conversely, where stopping a legitimate transaction would cause severe commercial loss and the applicant can be adequately compensated later, the court may refuse the injunction.

The court’s objective is not to give either party a tactical advantage. It is to preserve the status quo and ensure that the eventual judgment can be meaningfully enforced.

Irreparable harm and undertaking

Irreparable harm does not always mean financial loss. It means harm that cannot be adequately measured or compensated in money. The loss of a unique property, destruction of evidence, transfer of a controlling shareholding, or irreversible damage to a business relationship may qualify.

The applicant must also give an undertaking in damages. This is a serious commitment: if the injunction is later found to have been wrongly granted and the respondent suffers loss, the applicant may be required to pay compensation.

The undertaking protects respondents from abusive injunction applications. It ensures that a party cannot use a court order to freeze a transaction or damage a business without accepting the financial consequences if the claim ultimately fails.

Urgent and ex parte applications

Where delay would defeat the purpose of the injunction, the applicant may seek an ex parte injunction without first notifying the respondent. Such an order is exceptional and is usually granted only where there is a real risk of immediate and irreparable harm.

Even where an ex parte order is granted, it is normally temporary. The respondent must be given an opportunity to appear and respond at the next hearing. The court will then decide whether to maintain, vary, or discharge the injunction.

An ex parte applicant must make full and frank disclosure of all material facts, including facts that may weaken the application. Failure to do so may lead to the discharge of the injunction and may affect the applicant’s credibility.

Final note

An interlocutory injunction is a powerful remedy, but it is not automatic. The applicant must show a legal right, a serious issue, balance of convenience, irreparable harm, absence of delay, and a willingness to compensate the respondent if the injunction proves unjustified.

Before seeking an injunction, preserve evidence, act promptly, and assess whether damages would truly be inadequate. A properly granted injunction can preserve the subject matter of a dispute; a poorly supported application may expose the applicant to damages and weaken their credibility in the substantive case.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top