Someone Breached Your Contract—What Can You Actually Recover?

By Timileyin Ilesanmi

A breach of contract does not automatically mean that the innocent party will recover every loss they claim. Nigerian law recognises several remedies, but the most common is damages. The central question is not simply whether the other party breached the agreement; it is what loss flowed from that breach and whether the law permits recovery.

A party who suffers a breach may seek damages, specific performance, rescission, an injunction, or a claim on a quantum meruit. The appropriate remedy depends on the nature of the contract, the breach, and whether money can adequately repair the loss. What remedies are available to a party whose contractual rights have been breached, and how are damages assessed? The injured party must prove the contract, the breach, and the loss caused by the breach.

The purpose of contractual damages is compensatory, not punitive. The court seeks to place the innocent party, so far as money can do so, in the position it would have occupied had the contract been performed.

Damages for breach

Damages are the primary remedy for breach of contract. They compensate the claimant for loss suffered as a result of the breach, including loss of bargain, direct financial loss, and certain consequential losses.

The governing principle is derived from Hadley v. Baxendale (1854) 9 Exch. 341. Losses are recoverable where they arise naturally from the breach in the ordinary course of things, or where they were within the reasonable contemplation of both parties when the contract was made.

For example, if a supplier fails to deliver goods required for a project, the buyer may claim the additional cost of obtaining replacement goods. However, if the buyer claims an unusual and undisclosed loss, such as a massive penalty under a separate contract, the supplier may argue that the loss was too remote unless the special circumstances were communicated before the contract was made.

Mitigation of loss

An injured party cannot recover losses that could have reasonably been avoided. After a breach, the claimant must take reasonable steps to mitigate the loss, such as finding an alternative supplier, reselling goods, or reducing unnecessary expenditure.

The duty to mitigate does not require the claimant to take unreasonable risks, incur excessive expense, or sacrifice its commercial interests. It simply requires reasonable conduct in the circumstances. The defendant bears the burden of proving that the claimant failed to mitigate and that the failure caused avoidable loss.

A claimant who sits back and allows losses to accumulate may recover less than the full amount claimed. Conversely, a claimant who takes reasonable steps to reduce the loss may recover the remaining loss even if the mitigation was not perfectly successful.

Specific performance

Specific performance is an equitable remedy in which the court orders the breaching party to perform its contractual obligation. It is available where damages would be inadequate, such as in contracts for the sale of unique land or rare goods.

The court will not grant specific performance where damages are an adequate remedy, where performance would be impracticable, or where continued supervision by the court would be required. It is also discretionary and may be refused where the claimant has acted unfairly or has not fulfilled its own obligations.

In commercial disputes, specific performance may be sought for the transfer of land, delivery of unique goods, or completion of a transaction that cannot easily be replaced in the market.

Rescission and injunction

Rescission sets aside the contract and restores the parties, so far as possible, to their pre-contractual positions. It is commonly sought where the contract was induced by misrepresentation, fraud, duress, or fundamental mistake.

An injunction may be granted to restrain a party from doing something that would breach the contract or cause irreparable harm. For example, a court may restrain a former employee or business partner from disclosing confidential information or competing in breach of a valid restrictive covenant.

These remedies are discretionary. The claimant must act promptly and show that damages alone would not provide adequate protection.

Quantum meruit

Where one party has partially performed its obligations but the contract has been terminated or cannot be completed, the party may claim on a quantum meruit. This means a claim for the reasonable value of work done or services rendered.

This remedy is useful in construction, consultancy, and service contracts where work has been performed but payment has not been made. The claimant must prove the work done, its value, and the circumstances in which the contract was terminated.

Final note

A breach of contract gives the innocent party options, but not every loss is recoverable. Damages must be proven, must not be too remote, and must be mitigated where reasonably possible. Specific performance, rescission, injunctions, and quantum meruit are available only where their legal conditions are met.

Before pursuing a claim, review the contract, preserve correspondence and evidence of loss, and assess the real financial impact of the breach. A well-documented claim is more likely to succeed than a claim based only on allegations of wrongdoing.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top