By Timileyin Ilesanmi
Many commercial contracts contain an arbitration clause, but parties often ignore it when a dispute arises. One party may rush to court, while the other insists that the dispute must be resolved by an arbitrator. The question is whether the court can hear the case or must refer the parties to arbitration.
Under Nigerian law, an arbitration agreement is generally binding. Where a dispute falls within the agreement, the court will usually refer the parties to arbitration rather than allow one party to bypass the agreed dispute-resolution mechanism. The issue is whether a court may entertain a dispute that is subject to a valid arbitration agreement. The court must determine whether the parties agreed to arbitrate, whether the dispute falls within the scope of that agreement, and whether there is any legal reason why the agreement should not be enforced.
The governing statute is the Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023, which replaced the Arbitration and Conciliation Act. The Act limits court intervention in arbitration and requires courts to respect party autonomy.
The arbitration agreement
An arbitration agreement is an agreement by which parties submit present or future disputes to arbitration. It may be contained in a standalone agreement or as a clause within a commercial contract. The agreement must be clear enough to show that the parties intended arbitration rather than ordinary court litigation.
The clause should identify the disputes covered, the arbitral institution or procedure, the seat of arbitration, the number of arbitrators, and the language of proceedings. A poorly drafted clause may create disputes about the arbitration process itself, even where the parties clearly intended to arbitrate.
A party cannot simply ignore an arbitration clause because it prefers court litigation. Where the agreement is valid and covers the dispute, the other party may invoke it to prevent unnecessary court proceedings.
Court’s duty to refer
Section 5 of the Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023 provides that where a party brings a court action in respect of a matter covered by an arbitration agreement, the court must refer the parties to arbitration if a party requests it, unless the agreement is null, void, inoperative, or incapable of being performed.
This is a significant change from the former Arbitration and Conciliation Act. Under the old section 5, the court had discretion to stay proceedings where there was sufficient reason not to refer the dispute to arbitration. The new Act removes much of that discretion and aligns Nigerian law with the approach under the New York Convention.
The practical effect is that a party who files a court action despite an arbitration clause may find the case referred to arbitration. The court will not determine the merits of the dispute unless it finds that the arbitration agreement is invalid or cannot operate.
Exceptions to referral
The court may refuse referral where the arbitration agreement is null, void, inoperative, or incapable of being performed. This may arise where the agreement is unclear, where the agreed arbitral institution no longer exists, or where the parties cannot agree on a workable arbitration procedure.
The court may also refuse referral where the dispute falls outside the scope of the arbitration agreement. For example, a clause covering disputes relating to the supply of goods may not cover a separate claim for fraud or criminal conduct, unless the wording is broad enough to include it.
A party seeking to avoid arbitration must therefore show more than inconvenience or a preference for court. The party must establish a legal basis why the agreement should not be enforced.
Interim relief
Even where a dispute must be arbitrated, a party may still need urgent protection. The Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023 allows a party to seek interim measures from the court to preserve assets, maintain the status quo, prevent harm, or preserve evidence pending arbitration.
An application for urgent interim relief does not amount to a waiver of the arbitration agreement. The court may grant protective measures while leaving the substantive dispute to the arbitral tribunal.
The tribunal itself may also issue interim measures. These may include orders to preserve assets, maintain the status quo, or prevent a party from taking action that would prejudice the arbitration. Such measures are binding and may be enforced through the court.
Enforcement of awards
An arbitral award is not self-executing. The successful party must apply to a competent court for recognition and enforcement. Section 57 of the Arbitration and Mediation Act 2023 provides that an award is recognised as binding and may be enforced by the court, subject to the Act and to section 58.
The losing party may resist enforcement on limited grounds, such as lack of capacity, invalid arbitration agreement, lack of proper notice, inability to present its case, or breach of public policy. The court will not rehear the merits of the dispute as if it were an appeal.
Final note
An arbitration clause is not merely a suggestion. It is a binding agreement on how disputes will be resolved. A party who ignores it and rushes to court may find the case referred to arbitration, with time and cost wasted in the process.
Before filing a claim, review the dispute-resolution clause carefully. If arbitration is agreed, consider seeking urgent interim relief where necessary, but allow the arbitral tribunal to determine the substantive dispute. A well-drafted arbitration clause can save time and preserve party autonomy; a poorly understood one can create a second dispute about the dispute itself.