You Filed the Case, But Was the Defendant Properly Served?

By Timileyin Ilesanmi

Before a court can determine a claim against a defendant, the defendant must be properly served with the court process. Service is not a mere formality; it is the legal mechanism by which a defendant is notified of the claim and brought under the court’s jurisdiction.

A claimant may have a strong case, but if the originating process was not served in accordance with the applicable rules, the entire proceedings may be set aside. Service protects the defendant’s right to know the case against them and to respond. The claimant must establish that service was effected in the manner prescribed by the applicable court rules and any relevant statute.

Service may be personal, substituted, or, in limited circumstances, outside the court’s jurisdiction. The method chosen must be lawful. An irregular service may deprive the court of jurisdiction and render subsequent proceedings null and void.

Personal service

Personal service is the primary method of serving an originating process on an individual. It requires delivery of the process to the defendant personally, or in accordance with the rules permitting service on an adult at the defendant’s residence or place of business.

For a company, service is generally effected at its registered office or principal place of business, by delivering the process to a director, secretary, or other principal officer. Section 104 of the Companies and Allied Matters Act 2020 provides that court processes must be served on a company in the manner prescribed by the rules of court.

The claimant must ensure that the correct entity is served. Serving a company at the wrong address, or serving an officer who is not authorised to accept service, may render the service ineffective.

Substituted service

Substituted service is available where personal service cannot reasonably be effected. The claimant must apply to the court, usually by motion ex parte, supported by an affidavit explaining the efforts made to serve the defendant personally and proposing an alternative method of service.

The court may permit service by pasting at the defendant’s last known address, publication in a newspaper, electronic service, or any other method it considers effective and just. The order must specify the method, place, and period of service. Substituted service is not a shortcut. The claimant must show genuine attempts at personal service before the court will authorise an alternative method. A party cannot simply choose substituted service because it is more convenient.

Service on companies

Service on a company follows a different rule from service on an individual. In Mark v. Eke (2004) 5 NWLR (Pt. 865) 54, the Supreme Court held that substituted service cannot be effected on a company because the company can always be served at its registered office or through a principal officer.

The court explained that service on a company must be at its registered office, either by delivering the writ to a director, trustee, secretary, or other principal officer, or by leaving it at the company’s office. Service at a branch office may be ineffective, and an order permitting service of originating process on a company by courier may be set aside, since substituted service cannot be ordered against a company.

Service outside jurisdiction

Where the defendant resides or carries on business outside the court’s jurisdiction, the claimant may need leave to serve the process outside that jurisdiction. The applicable court rules and the Sheriffs and Civil Process Act prescribe the procedure and endorsement requirements.

Proof of service

Service must be proved. The process server must swear to an affidavit setting out the fact, date, time, place, and mode of service, and must describe the document served. A copy of the process served should be exhibited where required.

In Dannusa v. Barau  [2014] NGCA 10, the Court of Appeal held that an affidavit of service is prima facie proof of the matters stated in it, but where service is disputed, the court must scrutinise the affidavit and satisfy itself that service actually occurred.

The court cannot presume service. It must be established by clear, credible, and direct evidence. In Dannusa, the absence of any affidavit proving service of the motion for summary judgment led to the setting aside of the judgment entered against the defendant.

Final note

Service is the gateway to jurisdiction. A claimant must serve the correct defendant, at the correct address, using the correct method, and prove service through a proper affidavit.

For defendants, service is often the first line of defence. If the originating process was not properly served, the defendant may apply to set aside the proceedings. For claimants, careful attention to service at the outset can prevent wasted time, cost, and the risk of a judgment being overturned.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top