By Timileyin Ilesanmi
A defendant who ignores a court process may discover that judgment has been entered against them without a full trial. This is called a default judgment. It may be entered where a defendant fails to appear, fails to file a defence, or fails to take the required procedural steps.
Default judgment is a serious consequence of non-participation. However, it is not automatic in every case. The claimant must show proper service, and the defendant may in appropriate circumstances apply to have the judgment set aside. So, when may a court enter judgment against a defendant who has failed to appear or defend the claim? The court must first be satisfied that the defendant was properly served and that the applicable procedural conditions for default judgment have been met.
A default judgment may be entered in default of appearance or in default of pleadings. In default of appearance, the defendant fails to respond to the originating process. In default of pleadings, the defendant appears but fails to file a defence within the required time.
Service before judgment
Before a claimant may proceed in default, the claimant must prove service of the originating process. Order 8 Rule 1 of the Federal High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules 2019 provides that a plaintiff may proceed upon default of appearance only upon proof of service of the originating process.
Service is fundamental because it gives the defendant notice of the claim and an opportunity to respond. Where service is disputed, the court must satisfy itself that the originating process was actually served before proceeding to judgment.
An affidavit of service sworn by a bailiff or other authorised officer is prima facie evidence of service. However, it is not conclusive. Where the defendant challenges service with credible evidence, the court must determine the fact of service on the totality of the evidence.
Undefended list procedure
In debt-recovery and liquidated-demand claims, the claimant may place the suit on the undefended list. The defendant must file a notice of intention to defend, together with an affidavit disclosing a defence on the merits, within the time prescribed by the applicable rules.
In I.H. Ltd. v. Soneb Ent. Ltd. (2010) 4 NWLR (Pt. 1185) 561, the Supreme Court held that judgment can be entered in favour of the plaintiff in a suit under the undefended list procedure, without calling on the plaintiff to adduce oral evidence or to tender any document if the defendant fails to file a notice of intention to defend or if the trial court is satisfied from the affidavit filed by the defendant along with his notice of intention to defend the action, that no defence on the merit was disclosed by the defendant.
The affidavit must do more than deny the claim. It must disclose specific facts and documents that throw doubt on the claimant’s case. In Standard Chartered Bank Nigeria Ltd. v. Laniyan (SUIT NO: CV/2963/2018), the FCT High Court emphasised that the defendant’s affidavit must deal specifically with the plaintiff’s claim and state clearly the defence relied upon.
Setting aside default judgment
A defendant who wishes to set aside a default judgment must apply promptly and show good reason for the default. The court will consider whether the defendant had a good reason for failing to appear, whether there was undue delay in bringing the application, and whether the claimant would suffer prejudice if the matter were reheard.
The court will also consider whether the defendant’s case is manifestly unsupportable and whether the defendant’s conduct throughout the proceedings merits sympathetic consideration.
In Arik Air Ltd. v. Ekemezie (CA/L/647/2013) [2014] NGCA 21, the Court of Appeal restated the provisions of Order 8 Rule 10 of the Federal High Court (Civil Procedure) Rules: the application must be brought within the prescribed time, the applicant must pay the required penalty, a good defence must be attached, and the applicant must provide a just cause or explanation for the default.
Non-service and jurisdiction
Non-service of the originating process is a fundamental defect. It goes to the jurisdiction of the court and may justify setting aside the judgment, even where the claimant’s case is otherwise strong.
In NSITF Management Board v. Sonabel Medical Centre (SUIT NO: NIC/PHC/62/2024), the National Industrial Court considered an application to set aside a default judgment and consequential garnishee order. The court held that service of originating process is what confers jurisdiction on the court to adjudicate, and that a judgment entered without proper service may be set aside for lack of jurisdiction.
However, the court also held that where the defendant had sufficient constructive notice of the proceedings and chose to ignore them, the defendant could not complain of a denial of fair hearing.
Final note
A default judgment is not a punishment for missing a court date. It is a procedural consequence of failing to respond to a properly served claim. The claimant must prove service, and the defendant must show good reason and a meritorious defence to have the judgment set aside.
For claimants, ensure that service is properly effected and documented before seeking default judgment. For defendants, respond promptly to any court process. Ignoring a claim does not make it disappear; it may result in judgment being entered against you without a full trial.